← All finance posts

The Pro-Rata Trap: Why Your Backdoor Roth Cost You $3,000

2026-10-12 · Retirement / Roth IRA

You earn too much to contribute to a Roth IRA directly — in 2026, direct contributions phase out between $242,000 and $252,000 of MAGI for married couples filing jointly ($153,000–$168,000 single). So you did the textbook move: contribute $7,500 to a traditional IRA, don't deduct it, convert it to Roth the next day. Tax-free. Except it wasn't — because you had a $92,500 rollover IRA sitting at the same brokerage, and the IRS doesn't let you pick which dollars convert.

How the backdoor is supposed to work

The backdoor Roth is two steps: (1) make a nondeductible traditional IRA contribution — there's no income limit on contributing, only on deducting; (2) convert that balance to a Roth IRA — there's no income limit on conversions. Done cleanly, with zero other IRA balances, the conversion is essentially tax-free. The IRS has acknowledged the strategy for years and never challenged it. (Motley Fool's 2026 backdoor walkthrough, Bogleheads Roth IRA wiki)

The catch is one word: aggregation. For the pro-rata rule, the IRS treats all your traditional, SEP, and SIMPLE IRAs as one account. You cannot convert "just the after-tax dollars."

The math that blows it up

Meet Maya. She has a $92,500 rollover IRA (all pre-tax, from an old 401(k)) and contributes $7,500 nondeductible for 2026. Her total IRA balance: $100,000. Her after-tax basis: $7,500. She converts $7,500 to Roth.

Tax-free fraction = basis ÷ total balance = $7,500 ÷ $100,000 = 7.5%.

At 37% federal + 9.3% California, that "tax-free" conversion costs her $3,214 in extra tax. And the remaining $6,938 of basis stays trapped in the traditional IRA, complicating every future conversion. All because of Form 8606 math, which uses your IRA balance on December 31 of the conversion year — not the balance on conversion day.

Your $7,500 conversion under the pro-rata rule: what you thought vs what the IRS sees

Her spouse, who holds zero IRA balances anywhere, does the identical $7,500 backdoor the same week. His conversion: $0 tax. Same household, same week, $3,214 apart — the difference is entirely what sat in the account on December 31.

The fix: clear the decks before December 31

The standard repair is the reverse rollover: move the pre-tax IRA money into your current employer's 401(k) before year-end. 401(k)s aren't in the aggregation rule, so once the pre-tax dollars leave your IRAs, your December 31 IRA balance is $0 (or just your nondeductible contribution), and the conversion goes through clean.

The sequence that works:

The clean backdoor Roth sequence: clear pre-tax balances before you convert

Same $7,500 conversion: the tax bill with the rollover left in place vs moved into a 401(k)

One critical detail: only roll the pre-tax portion into the 401(k). After-tax basis can't go into a 401(k). If the account grew or shrank, do the conversion first or keep the basis amount in cash so you don't accidentally push nondeductible dollars into the plan.

What not to do

Takeaways

Further reading: Bogleheads Roth IRA wiki for the income tables, Motley Fool's 2026 backdoor Roth guide for the step-by-step, and the IRS 2026 COLA limits page for the official $7,500 / $8,600 figures.

Not tax, legal, or investment advice. Check your own situation and talk to a professional before acting.

← All finance posts